It is suggested that if in fact God makes a statement concerning one, such a he did Judas when he said ‘one of you ‘is’ a devil, does that mean because that is the way things are, that it is the way it of necessity have been from the beginning? Is it possible for God to know the decisions that men will make without necessitating them as ‘evil’ and ‘devils’ from the beginning? In Acts we find that God ‘added to the Church.’ If the proponets of the ‘Judas was a devil from the beginning' are consistent, this would be an impossibility for God to add any to the church, seeing that they either were part of the church from eternity past or they were not. All is either necessitated as it is or not. Which is it? Necessitated fatalism or not? Can God add or not?