Who's your guy's favorite NFL player? My currently active one is hands down Donovan McNabb. I think the guy does it all, run and throw, better than anyone. Let me clairify, I believe he has the best combonation of the two, Manning is a better pure passer, and Vick is a better runner. My historically favorite was John Elway. He did the most with the least his entire career. I mean no lead was insurmountable with the " John Wayne," of football on your team.