And yet, that's the question you are answering with your non sequitur. :laugh: Why does a sow wallow in the mire? Charlie: because it's not a dove. Why does a dog return to its vomit? Charlie: because it's not a sheep. Why does the sinner reject Christ? Charlie: because he isn't elect. Non sequitur, and wrong. A sow wallows in the mire, because it's a sow, and that's its nature. A dog returns to its vomit, because it's a dog, and that's its nature. A sinner rejects Christ, because he's a sinner, and that's his nature.