I ask this question every year or so to some friends, so I'll post in here: In your mind, who is the most deserving player who is NOT in Baseball's Hall of Fame? Who would you induct tomorrow if you had the power to do so? Just ONE. We'll get others later, but right now I want your absolute #1 pick. Let's exclude Peter Edward Rose for two reasons. (1) He seems to be the obvious modern choice in the media and also among fans from every league and team, and (2) He's ineligible. Who would you pick?