Seems the second toe should be a little shorter than the big toe and the rest should taper down to the little toe. But SOME people I know have triangle shaped feet; that seems a bit abnormal to me, how can they ever run properly? Edit:can't figure out how to post poll? Sorry, maybe someone can fix this for me? Big toe is the longest toe. Second toe is same length as big toe. Second toe is slightly shorter. Second toe is longer than big toe. Second and third toe are longer than big toe.