what do you think?

agedman · Mar 14, 2016

Below was taken from A Brief Explanation of "New Covenant Theology"
by Fred G. Zaspel

NCT and the More Traditional Systems of Interpretation
Click to expand...

Covenant Theologyis designed to show the unity in God's purpose in human redemption. It is called "covenant" theology not because of an emphasis on the Biblical/historical covenants as such but on certain theological covenants -- the covenant of redemption, the covenant of works, and the covenant of grace. The covenant of grace is essentially the promise made in Gen.3:15 of the coming deliverer, and all of history is viewed as a progressive unfolding of this covenant. Thus, the New Covenant, in Covenant Theology, is not understood as a new covenant actually; it is rather a new "administration" of the covenant of grace, as was the Mosaic Covenant before it. One covenant with various administrations is the essence of Covenant Theology on this point. Therefore, the Old Covenant is seen as an essentially gracious covenant, not a legal one. Further, with this emphasis on the unity of God's purpose there is a strong tendency in Covenant Theology to carry over the old order into the new: Israel is the church, the law of the Old Covenant is the law of the New, and so on.

Dispensational Theology emphasizes rather the various differencesin God's dealings with men. A "dispensation" has to do with the various administrations of Divine truth. With new revelation come new responsibilities and/or privileges. This change results in a new "economy" or dispensation. With this emphasis on the various changes in God's program, Dispensationalism labors to show the differences between the old and new economies or dispensations. For the (traditional) dispensationalist, there are two separate peoples of God running through all history and even eternity, law is a thing of the past and not relevant to the New Covenant believer, and so on.

NCT claims simply to have middle ground between these two. We are not satisfied with the simple "one covenant -- two administrations" idea of Covenant Theology. In our judgment this results in a rather "flat" reading of Scripture which fails to appreciate the advance, the distinctively "new" character of this Messianic age. Nor are we satisfied with the over-compartmentalizing tendency of Dispensational Theology. In our judgment its "no law" and "two equal peoples" notions failed to appreciate the unity of God's nature and purpose. And so we find ourselves somewhere between the two traditional answers. We are happy to see representative scholars from both sides of the discussion moving toward center in their respective discussions of various particular issues involved, and we are more comfortable with the progress they offer.
Click to expand...

He concludes with the following statement:

Much of this is more a matter of differing emphases than of differing theology -- it is, after all, an "in house" debate. And there are other (lesser) questions which the discussion generates, such as the role of law in preaching the gospel, the role of law / grace in sanctification, the role of Divine law in human government, the relation of Christ to Moses, the role of creeds, and so on. All these questions find answers of differing emphasis even within each respective theological camp, and finding that right emphasis is the pursuit of those on all sides who are concerned with discovering a more precise understanding of God's revelation in Scripture.
Click to expand...

Is the great amount of discussion on the BB over these views a "matter of differing emphases (rather) than of differing theology?"

What is "that right emphasis" in which the believer should strive in discovering "a more precise understanding of God's revelation in Scripture."

Deacon · Mar 14, 2016

It's curious that Covenant Theology seems to be becoming more dispensational and Dispensational Theology is becoming more covenantal; the most prominent separation being eschatologcal.

Rob

what do you think?

agedman Well-Known Member
Site Supporter

Deacon Well-Known Member
Site Supporter

Useful Searches

what do you think?

agedman Well-Known Member Site Supporter

Deacon Well-Known Member Site Supporter

agedman Well-Known Member
Site Supporter

Deacon Well-Known Member
Site Supporter