It goes like this: God is not in charge of everything because, if he is, then he intended for terrible things like the acts of Jeffry Dalmer to come to pass. Enter logic-blinding, Scripture-skewing powerful emotions. Once you get here it does not matter WHAT the Bible says- you will refuse to accept it because you do not like it. Once you "feel" so strongly about something, logic is out the window and with it goes truth. This is how "homosexual Christians" interpret the Scripture. They have extremely powerful feelings about their lifestyle and they CANNOT see the condemnation of homosexuality in the Scriptures. They just cannot IMAGINE a God who would condemn something so sacred to them. So they can't see it. Some of you CANNOT IMAGINE a God who would will horrible things to come to pass, things that God HATES, so that those things can bring about an infinitely great and holy ETERNAL purpose. But here's my point. Saying "You're WRONG!!! God would NEVER ordain such a thing!!! You are EVIL for suggesting that God intended in eternity past for these horrible things to happen!!!" is not an argument. It is nothing but blind emotion. The Catholic just can't IMAGINE a God who would not require works in order to save. It does not matter what the Bible says. The Catholic is already blinded by powerful emotions. But he cannot argue against it exegetically (from the Scripture). But he does not CARE. HIS GOD would never save anyone without requiring them to do works. Just because you SAY "God would never..." does not mean that Scripture agrees with you. And it is not an argument. It is nothing more than an emotional, unwarranted claim.