• Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.

    Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.

    We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!

And so it begins...

targus

New Member
The reporter makes it clear that it was the driver's "claim" and not a verified story.

Let's see what the response is from the INS and the police that took him to the INS (
if that is what actually happened) before drawing conclusions.

I have no doubt that there is more to the story.
 

Crabtownboy

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
The reporter makes it clear that it was the driver's "claim" and not a verified story.

Let's see what the response is from the INS and the police that took him to the INS (
if that is what actually happened) before drawing conclusions.

I have no doubt that there is more to the story.

It was the ICE, Immigration and Customs Enforcement, not the INS and they said it was simply standard operating procedures. I wonder how many other truckers have been ask to show their birth certificate at this weighting station before this incidence.

How much identification do you want a person to carry. Isn't a commercial drivers license and a social security number enough?

Have you ever heard of this being done before?

Do you think he would even have been asked for identification if he were white?

 

matt wade

Well-Known Member
MP, you should be thankful for the new immigration law. It would have stopped this incident from happening. If you would read the bill, you would see it says:

Specifies that a person is presumed to be lawfully present if the person provides any of the following:

Ø A valid Arizona driver license.

Ø A valid Arizona nonoperating identification license.

Ø A valid tribal enrollment card or other form of tribal identification.

Ø A valid federal, state or local government issued identification, if the issuing entity requires proof of legal presence before issuance.

So, now that this law is in effect, the police officers have been told exactly what forms of identification are acceptable. One of those documents that is acceptable is a "valid Arizona driver license". The driver from this story presented that license. Had this law been in effect, he would have not had a problem at all.

New law for the win!
 

targus

New Member
I wonder how many other truckers have been ask to show their birth certificate at this weighting station before this incidence.

We don't even know if it happened in this instance.

As I pointed out the reporter's story was simply that this guy "claimed".

There was no verification of the events as reported.
 

Crabtownboy

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
We don't even know if it happened in this instance.

As I pointed out the reporter's story was simply that this guy "claimed".

There was no verification of the events as reported.

What would convince you it happened?

How many links would you like?

#
#
News results for arizona truck driver birth certificate
No racial profiling in Arizona. Or Georgia either.

‎ - 58 minutes ago
On the other hand, there's this: Last week, an Arizona truck driver pulled ... there until his wife could bring a birth certificate documenting that the man ...
Atlanta Journal Constitution (blog) - 5 related articles »
The new birthers: Arizona truck driver arrested, forced to show ...

‎ - Iowa Independent - 27 related articles »
#
Below The Beltway » Blog Archive » Arizona Truck Driver Forced To ...

Apr 25, 2010 ... Arizona Truck Driver Forced To Show Birth Certificate To Prove He's A Citizen. by Doug Mataconis @ 5:20 pm on April 25, 2010. ...
belowthebeltway.com/.../arizona-truck-driver-forced-to-show-birth-certificate-to-prove-hes-a-citizen/ - Cached
#
The new birthers: Arizona truck driver arrested, forced to show ...

- 2 visits - 11:09am
The new birthers: Arizona truck driver arrested, forced to show birth certificate. By John Tomasic 4/26/10 12:00 PM. A Latino truck driver outside Phoenix ...
iowaindependent.com/.../the-new-birthers-arizona-truck-driver-arrested-forced-to-show-birth-certificate - Cached
#
Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial ...

Apr 21, 2010 ... Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial-profiling · Tempe police looking into missing Arizona State student ...
www.azfamily.com/.../Man-says-he-wa...ed-to-provide-birth-certificate-91769419.html - Cached
#
Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial ...

Apr 21, 2010 ... Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial-profiling .... This bill is unconstitutional, and the state of Arizona will go ...
www.azfamily.com/news/91769419.html - Cached
Show more results from www.azfamily.com
#
AZ Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial ...

Re: AZ Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims rac. Sun, 04/25/2010 - 10:29 — Phoenix Justice. Arizona is already broke, thanks to the Grover ...
videocafe.crooksandliars.com/.../az-truck-driver-forced-show-birth-certifica - Cached
#
TPF: Arizona Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims ...

Apr 22, 2010 ... Arizona Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial-profiling · Senator Graham's Gay Scandal Goes National and Viral ...
www.the-peoples-forum.com/cgi-bin/readart.cgi?ArtNum=18187 - Cached
#
Arizona Truck Driver Arrested: Not carrying a Birth Certificate

- 10:31am
10 posts - 8 authors - Last post: 2 days ago
Well, here comes the first lawsuit folks!!! This interruption into these two citizens lives has cost them both a days pay. Truck carriers ...
www.arguewitheveryone.com/.../11998...-arrested-not-carrying-birth-certificate.html - Cached
Get more discussion results
#
The Liberal Curmudgeon: Arizona Truck Driver Handcuffed For Not ...

Apr 26, 2010 ... Arizona Truck Driver Handcuffed For Not Having Birth Certificate. Governor Jan Brewer (R) of Arizona signed a new immigration law that gives ...
www.theliberalcurmudgeon.com/.../arizona-truck-driver-handcuffed-for-not.html - Cached
#
Newsvine - Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims ...

Apr 25, 2010 ... Truck driver forced to show birth certificate claims racial-profiling ..... So while it might be popular to flail away at Arizona for their ...
susanduncan.newsvine.com/_.../4203583-truck-driver-forced-to-show-birth-certificate-claims-racial-profiling - Cached
#
AMERICAblog News: American-born truck driver handcuffed in Arizona ...

American-born truck driver handcuffed in Arizona for driving without his birth certificate. by John Aravosis (DC) on 4/25/2010 07:00:00 PM ...
www.americablog.com/2010/.../american-born-truck-driver-handcuffed.html
 

targus

New Member
What would convince you it happened?

How many links would you like?

Did you read your own links?

How about if you go through them first and then pick the one out that talks about verification of the "claim".

I'm not accepting your homework assignsments at this time.
 

matt wade

Well-Known Member
Every single one of those links has the same source. Try dealing with the primary souce Crabby...the primary source in this instance is the original news broadcast (it's the closest we can get). The original news broadcast says that it was a claim and not verfied.
 

rbell

Active Member
Every single one of those links has the same source. Try dealing with the primary souce Crabby...the primary source in this instance is the original news broadcast (it's the closest we can get). The original news broadcast says that it was a claim and not verfied.

But if he dealt with the primary source, he might not get to scream "racism!"
 

targus

New Member
Every single one of those links has the same source. Try dealing with the primary souce Crabby...the primary source in this instance is the original news broadcast (it's the closest we can get). The original news broadcast says that it was a claim and not verfied.

I knew that would be the case - that's why I refused to do Crabby's work for him.

He has a nasty little habit of googling a subject and then throwing out the search results as a homework assignment.

I won't do Crabby's homework assignments any more.

He has to learn to read his sources first and then post them.

Although it is funny when his source actually says the opposite of what he hopes it does.:laugh:
 

Robert Snow

New Member
I'm sure targus and wade will admit the error of this detention once all the facts are in, right? :rolleyes:

It seems strange that ICE had no response except to "look into the incident."
 

matt wade

Well-Known Member
I'm sure targus and wade will admit the error of this detention once all the facts are in, right? :rolleyes:

It seems strange that ICE had no response except to "look into the incident."

Where have I said that the detention was lawful or unlawful? I don't have enough facts to make that sort of decision yet.

(btw, I thought you wanted to make peace or something...why do you continue to act like this then? I've laid off you, yet you can't do the same?)
 

targus

New Member
I'm sure targus and wade will admit the error of this detention once all the facts are in, right? :rolleyes:

Sure. Glad to. If I miss it be sure to call me on it. :)

It seems strange that ICE had no response except to "look into the incident."

Not strange at all. That is one of the things that makes me think that there is more to this than this truck drivers claim.
 

Crabtownboy

Well-Known Member
Site Supporter
Not strange at all. That is one of the things that makes me think that there is more to this than this truck drivers claim.

Actually they did respond stating they were only following standard procedures. I noted that in an earlier post.

Does that make it official enough?


As I asked before, I wonder how many times in the last year ICE agents have ask a person to produce a birth certificate at this truck weighing station?
 

matt wade

Well-Known Member
As I asked before, I wonder how many times in the last year ICE agents have ask a person to produce a birth certificate at this truck weighing station?

What does it matter? Did you miss the part where I posted that this new law will clarify and define what documents are acceptable? The new law makes it clear to officers what they, by law, have to accept as identification. Currently they don't have a law to clearly define that for them.
 

targus

New Member
Actually they did respond stating they were only following standard procedures. I noted that in an earlier post.

Does that make it official enough?



As I asked before, I wonder how many times in the last year ICE agents have ask a person to produce a birth certificate at this truck weighing station?

Good for you.

Now let's look at this.

If they were ICE agents then it is not the product of the Arizona bill.

Now what you need to do is find the answers to your own question.

How many times in the last year did ICE agents ask a person to produce a birth certificate at this truch weighing station?

Get back to me when you find your answer. :)
 
Top