Ariz. may require hospitals to check citizenship

Aw, come on, Paul...you know better than that.

You couldn't be more wrong, no matter how hard you tried. Of course it's illegal

 

So, you just made a judgmental decision about me. How "not of Christ" of you. I requested the money from you, you should not make any judgments about me or ask me any questions. In order to show compassion you must simply give me the money.

I'll be waiting for it, hypocrite.

 

I did not judge. I made a statement of my lack of knowledge ... not your need. Christ never told us to be stupid! The Good Samaritan saw the need and responded. As I said, if I lived near you and knew of your need then I would respond.

But how about sending me $1200 so I can give it to four students here who come from very poor circumstances in Eastern Europe. I will not use it. They have need of it.

 

You didn't judge? You said "No, you might waste the money." That's not judging me? If you had a true Christ-like attitude you would trust me.

 

He said , No.

Imagine that.:laugh:

 

Liberals are great moralists and will cram their superiority down your throat every chance they get.

 

So in Crabby's hypothetical he tells us that if he knew of someone's need he would help.

And then goes on to tell us about someones actual need - someone that he does know...

And instead of telling us that he is helping them asks others to help them.

And that is a perfect example of liberal charity - use other people's money.

 

Being an illegal alien is illegal; I never said otherwise. I said it's not a crime. For example, when the government acts to deport an illegal alien, it launches a civil action, not a criminal one.

 

Illegal entry into the country is a crime - subject to both criminal and civil penalties.

(a) Improper time or place; avoidance of examination or inspection;
misrepresentation and concealment of facts
Any alien who (1) enters or attempts to enter the United States
at any time or place other than as designated by immigration
officers, or (2) eludes examination or inspection by immigration
officers, or (3) attempts to enter or obtains entry to the United
States by a willfully false or misleading representation or the
willful concealment of a material fact, shall, for the first
commission of any such offense, be fined under title 18 or
imprisoned not more than 6 months, or both, and, for a subsequent
commission of any such offense, be fined under title 18, or
imprisoned not more than 2 years, or both.

http://codes.lp.findlaw.com/uscode/8/12/II/VIII/1325

 

Is it immoral of the Mexican government to have an economic & law enforcement system so dismal & corrupt that their citizens have to break the laws of another country to seek treatment ?

As usual, the only purpose these "victims" serve C.T.Boy is to back up his view of himself as a superior Christian.

 

Under the proposed law hospitals cannot give medical treatment for non-life threatening conditions to anyone before the patient proves they are legally in the country.

Note in the quote from the proposed law that all potential patients must be checked ... not just ones people who are suspected of being illegal aliens.

So if you are taken into the hospital with a broken arm or leg ... not a life threatening problem ... how would you feel hurting and waiting until your spouse, friend or whoever went to your home to get proper identification, whatever that is, to show you are legally a US citizen? What is proper identification? From what I see in the proposed bill proper identification is not defined. If someone can find this information for me I would appreciate it very much.

From the proposed law:

So if you are taken into the hospital with a broken arm or leg ... not a life threatening problem ... how would you feel hurting and waiting until your spouse, friend or whoever went to your home to get proper identification, whatever that is, to show you are legally a US citizen?

 

In the first place, a broken leg or arm do require emergency treatment. Being a "life threatening problem" is not a requirement. You made that up.

In the second place, got an Arizona drivers license or ID card,? You're in.

It's amazing how little understanding you have of anything you read.

Dramatizing a misrepresentation is not working out for you.

 

From the proposed law:

I see nothing here that exempts a broken arm or leg. So, you are there hurting until you or someone can provide documentation proving you are legal.

Also, there are people who do not drive and have no drivers license.

Where did you get this information. It is not in the proposed law. It is not all that hard for an illegal to come by a drivers license.

Please give me a link to the information. Thanks.

Apparently you did not read the proposed bill.

 

Only a life-threatening condition qualifies as an emergency? We ought to hope our local fire departments don't define it that way.

"This is 9-1-1. State the nature of your emergency."

"My house is on fire!"

"Is anyone inside your house?"

"No!"

'Well, then, you should have called the listed number for the fire department. This line is for emerencies only." [Clop]

 

It doesn't. He made it up.

But once he starts down that misrepresentation path, there is no stopping him. Facts don't matter.

He'll defend his lie to the bitter end.

 

Yes, it is. Try reading it.


1. AN ARIZONA DRIVER LICENSE ISSUED AFTER 1 9 9 6 OR AN ARIZONA
NONOPERATING I D E N T I F I C A T I O N LICENSE.

2 . A BIRTH CERTIFICATE OR DELAYED BIRTH CERTIFICATE ISSUED I N ANY
STATE, TERRITORY OR POSSESSION OF THE UNITED STATES.

3. A UNITEO STATES CERTIFICATE OF BIRTH ABROAD.

4. A UNITEO STATES PASSPORT.

5 . A FOREIGN PASSPORT WITH A UNITED STATES V I S A .

6. AN 1 - 9 4 FORM WITH A PHOTOGRAPH.

7. A UNITED STATES C I T I Z E N S H I P AND IMMIGRATION SERVICES EMPLOYMENT
AUTHORIZATION DOCUMENT OR REFUGEE TRAVEL DOCUMENT.

8. A UNITED STATES CERTIFICATE OF NATURALIZATION.

9. A UNITED STATES CERTIFICATE OF C I T I Z E N S H I P .

1 0 . A T R I B A L CERTIFICATE OF I N D I A N BLOOD.

11. A T R I B A L OR BUREAU OF I N D I A N AFFAIRS A F F I O A V I T OF BIRTH.

B. FOR THE PURPOSES OF ADMINISTERING THE ARIZONA HEALTH CARE COST
CONTAINMENT SYSTEM, DOCUMENTATION OF C I T I Z E N S H I P AND LEGAL RESIDENCE SHALL
CONFORM WITH THE REQUIREMENTS OF T I T L E XIX OF THE SOCIAL SECURITY ACT.