I'm going to say you should give this girl a break and try extremely hard not to make litmus-test judgements before you get to know her, especially about which famous ministries she likes or doesn't like.
-Is she committed to knowing Christ and his word, and serving people, and building her life on the Gospel? If so, give her a chance, cuz that in itself is rare.
-Does she have an evident joy in her walk with God?
Given that there are so many people on this board who have had trouble finding a good church...she likely chose the church she did because she wanted to go to a church that seemed to teach the bible and work to reach people and build up believers...whether they have a drum-set or a video ministry, or coffee in the narthex shouldn't really matter.
Look at the biblical desciptions of a godly woman from Prov. 31, Ephesians, and others, and if she fits these, but still doesn't really care for David Jeremiah, Way of the Master, or John MacArthur...I'd say you've still found a winner!
(you may want to have a conversation or two about your views of Election, however... I know a Calvinist who married a Nazarene...and they have a great, loving marraige that they use to minister to lots of people...but they had to talk though those issues soon after their wedding when it came to light...they have agreed to disagree...neither changed their minds, but they still get along...imagine that!)