matt wade said:
I agree. I'm not a fan of Palin, but it isn't her fault if the policy is changed after she files her taxes (in fact the policy was revisted because of what she filed!).
Anyway, the bigger issue here is charging the state of Alaska per diem for staying in your own house. I may be to the letter of the law (and now that letter says you have to pay taxes on it), but it certainly isn't in the spirit. If you are running as a conservative, you should be nickel and diming on your per diem charges.
I'm not a particularly great fan of some politicians, either, but resent one implication in this post, namely the "nickel and diming" bit, while assuming that it may meet the "letter of the law" meaning the wording of the statute or regulations. I happen to be a farmer, and I do our own taxes. For many years, before I was married, I also did the taxes of my several family members, at no charge to any of them. Most of them have now since passed from this life, including my own brother.
(FTR, my wife's brother is an accountant, so we certainly do not have to go this route, but I still choose to.) I seek every possible exemption and deduction, I can find. I do not believe there is any moral or ethical obligation to meet some implied yet undefined and unspoken "spirit of the law" that allegedly lies behind the law. I choose not to give "one red cent" more (or less) than is required by law, to Washington or Frankfort, save rounding to the nearest dollar amount. I do not believe anyone is a "tax cheat" for taking advantage of every possible exemption and deduction, which is the implied premise that lies behind this whole thread.
FTR, as it is, we have chosen to allow the Governments to use our money for a year, at no interest, due to not claiming more exemptions on the W-2, which we are certainly allowed to do, fully legally. Hence, I believe in this, I/we have far gone beyond what the law requires. Our total refunds have always been fairly substantial, FWIW.
In fact, there are multiple different ways I can compute the taxes that are due for the state returns, unlike the federal return, where there is only one. The actual difference will usually never exceed a couple of bucks, and more often than not, does not result in any difference, yet I take about 2-3 hours, on average, just to run all of the alternatives to the tax table, and file the one with the least tax owed, resulting in the largest refund. I assure you I can find better and more profitable uses for three hours than to 'save a dollar in taxes', but I do this on principle.
Ed