Why did I think that you might be past mocking, Joseph?
Here, from http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/diseases/flu/fluinfo.htm
Now, would anyone care to tell me how SARS is different from flu?
Types of influenze viruses -- including the fact that they are transmissable in some cases from animals: http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/diseases/flu/viruses.htm
Please note the four myths in the chart at the bottom of this page: http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/diseases/flu/facts.htm
From here: http://familydoctor.org/handouts/477.html
The vaccine contains three different influenza strains. These are chosen during the previous season based upon which strains were most prevalent during the preceding year, which strains are circulating in other areas of the world (e.g. China), and which strains can be easily incorporated into the new vaccine.
http://www.canadianchiropractor.ca/Past_Issues.htm?ID=720
Influenza virus strains mutate, necessitating a new vaccine each year. Technicians affiliated with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) collect influenza viruses from pigs and people in foreign lands, e.g., China.
CDC personnel then attempt to predict which viruses will infect people in the United States the following year-the CDC crystal ball. These CDC-selected viruses are distributed to vaccine manufacturers early in the year for influenza vaccine production for administration that autumn.
Predicting which influenza viruses from China, for instance, will infect people in Dayton, Ohio, a year later involves a fair amount of guesswork. Flu shot history is replete with examples of poor matches between influenza viruses in the vaccine and those actually infecting people.
http://www.vaccineinfo.net/immunization/vaccine/influenza/flu_vaccine_facts.shtml
(I keep finding the references to China and the Orient, but am running out of the time I alot myself for web searches to give you the definitive reference I would like to on this)
Man O man O man! This one does it for me! SARS was not only predicted, but predicted exactly as a flu outbreak a couple of years ago! Here you go:
http://www.fluwatch.com/output_news_1.cfm?pageid=65&ID=37
Joseph, in short, I do my homework. I have also raised six kids, cared for dozens of fosters, and know for sure that flu is NOT stomach upset! If your doctor thinks it is, please print this off and give it to him. Thank you.
News: SARS, the fake and manufactured epidemic?
Discussion in '2003 Archive' started by Helen, May 3, 2003.
Page 2 of 3
-
Peter, cut the hot air and give me some references for your claims, please.
-
>>>>>Flu kills. It kills primarily the older, the already sick, and the very young.
Is SARS simply another strain of flu?<<<<<
..........................................
The key point Helen, that you have missed, is that the death rate from SARS is more than 50 times the death rate from ordinary flu. Does it have symptoms very similar to flu? Yes, sure it does and the symptoms are similar to other types of illnesses. But the death rate is not similar and there is strong evidence that this virus is far more deadly than other flu causing viruses.
As for profit motive, you might want to consider that Steve Ransom also has a profit motive. He sells books and apparently one can make a living by lying about AIDS and other diseases, as he has done. -
Please reference your statistic for "50 times more", Peter.
-
>>>>>>Joseph, in short, I do my homework. I have also raised six kids, cared for dozens of fosters, and know for sure that flu is NOT stomach upset! If your doctor thinks it is, please print this off and give it to him. Thank you.<<<<<<
You are misrepresenting what Joseph said. He only said that he gets flu frequently. What is frequently? Well the medical authorities say that about 10 to 20 percent of the population get it each year, so that is not inconsistent with what Joseph said. He never said that he was talking about stomach upsets. I don't think you are in position to give advice to medical doctors, as you seem to suggest in the above. -
-
Originally posted by Helen:
Why did I think that you might be past mocking, Joseph?Click to expand...
Joseph Botwinick -
never met or corresponded with the guy. Have no idea who he is at all. I just recognized some intelligent questions and observations.
edit: Peter, unless you give some references for your claims, there is no reason at all anyone should believe what you are saying. Who are you to make your claims?
IN addition -- anyone who gets real influenza 'frequently' should be hospitalized just as often -- he has a compromised immune system and will probably be dead soon. -
What good points did he make? I just didn't see any.
Joseph Botwinick -
Then read my posts for my questions, Joseph. Is SARS simply a fancy name for another flu outbreak? Have you actually read any of the references I have posted? Do you REALLY think you get the real flu 'frequently'?
Isn't it time you educated yourself a little instead of trying to bait me? -
I might ask the same question of you. Speaking of which, I know you are a very intelligent person. But for the record, would you please state what your educational background is?
Thanks,
Joseph Botwinick
PS: Generally, when one cannot continue defending their position, they resort to personal attacks as you have done. Interesting. -
I am not depending on my educational background, which is not in medicine. I have educated myself in this particular subject for this particular thread by looking things up on the web, which I referenced for you. If you would like to check the credentials of the authors of those articles, please feel free.
-
Originally posted by Helen:
I am not depending on my educational background, which is not in medicine.Click to expand... -
Just curious. What, exactly, is your educational background?
Joseph Botwinick -
This is the third page, which means this will be closed soon. In the meantime, not one of my questions has been answered. I have been challenged, baited and mocked, but no questions have been answered by anyone and no references given for some questionable claims.
The more I am looking into this, the more I am beginning to suspect that the very name "SARS" was made up to make this thing sound new and thus help manufacture panic.
There is plenty to be worried about with a flu outbreak, and one which seems to spread quickly as this may be doing. That is enough for concern. But what the press and someone or some group behind the press is doing seems irresponsible to me. My suspician is growing that something is going on here that we don't know about.
And why attack me for asking questions? That is an interesting phenomenon, too. Is it that the press, God bless all their ink, is to be believed no matter what they print? Is it that whatever news the networks choose to share is God's total truth?
I doubt both of those things highly.
Why are people afraid of questions? Why am I getting mocked regarding my doubts about this SARS thing being something 'new'?
Why are people afraid to educate themselves? Are we now so afraid of the 'experts' that we think we have no brains with which to think for ourselves? -
Originally posted by Joseph_Botwinick:
Just curious. What, exactly, is your educational background?
Joseph BotwinickClick to expand... -
Originally posted by Helen:
</font><blockquote>quote:</font><hr />Originally posted by Joseph_Botwinick:
Just curious. What, exactly, is your educational background?
Joseph BotwinickClick to expand...
Joseph Botwinick -
>>>>>Please reference your statistic for "50 times more", Peter. <<<<
I calculated it from information readily available on the Internet. You can do the same if you wish, and if you come up with something different, post it here. I don't think you do your homework at all. Otherwise you would have known that many of the answers to your questions about SARS are available on the Internet. I am not going to spoon feed you though. You can find them with just a slight amount of searching. -
>>>>>Enough to teach for almost 30 years and then go into science editing. <<<<<
Seems to me that you are inflating your resume a little here with regard to "science editing". -
Disregard it if you like. It makes no difference to me. Where are your references for your claims?
Joseph, I'm 55. I was born at 4:08 a.m. the morning of February 29, 1948. I graduated from high school in the famous year of 1965 (near Berkeley, even!), and from college in 1972 (I took a couple of years off in the middle and worked with horses in Lancaster, California). I started teaching at 22 but there were some gaps, so I just say 'about 30' years. I have taught in both the public and private venues. My first job was private, teaching young men incarcerated after the Watts riots of the 60's who were supposed to be both retarded and delinquent. Of the 22 in that class, I think about three were honestly retarded; the others had simply chosen to specialize in things other than academics.
I put in my stint as a sub after that, quit when I had Scott, went back later, and it continued pretty steadily after that despite a move across the state, until I took time off for a couple of years when my oldest daughter was diagnosed with RSD (Reflex sympathetic dystrophy) and then finished by teaching a number of classes at the county level for both charter families and kids who were not able to be in the public school classrooms for one reason or another (two actors, two on chemotherapy, several with deaf parents -- English is their second language and the school system often misses that -- and that sort of thing). I'm not going to put down my CV here, and this kind of personal challenge is exactly what is NOT supposed to be part of these threads. But there is all the answer I feel like taking the time for.
Now, what is the problem with the questions asked about SARS and why are you avoiding them and concentrating on me?
Page 2 of 3