Well I hope you guys didn't hold hands while in college:)
This couple does hold hands so I think they are more than friends just rooming together.
Also, 1 Cor 7:9 says it is better to marry than burn.
Marriage Problem
Discussion in 'Pastoral Ministries' started by steveo, Jun 3, 2004.
Page 2 of 3
-
Roommates are different than lovers. I lived with a variety of roommates prior to marriage. Now I live with my wife.
Roommates may live together (hopefully without open immorality or hidden lust) -
[qutoe]Roommates may live together (hopefully without open immorality or hidden lust) [/quote]That seems to be the case here, based on the OP.
BTW, I am not recommending or endorsing what this couple is doing. I am questioning whether they are actually doing anything that the Bible forbids. -
Pastor Larry,
Proverbs 31 displays the biblical responsibilities of a wife- and shows that a marriage relationship is much more than physical.
Other passages such as Ephesians 5 show us that marriage is about love and submission, not just physical indulgence in one another.
I don't know about you and your room mates, but when I roomed with other guys, it was chaotic and unstructured- far different than the orderly partnership my wife and I share. To describe a college roommate situation with other men as cohabitation in this context is quite ludicrous. Now, if you and your college room mates were enjoying exclusive benefits of companionship (even if they were not physical/sexual), we would all start to wonder about you. Chances are, you shared very little with them other than a room, and when you did share more, it caused friction and discomfort.
And, referring to steveo's couple, if you and your college roomies were holding hands on a regular basis, I'd have a problem with you cohabiting as well.
bottom line: If it's wrong for the grandkids, it should be wrong for the grandparents as well. -
-
Let me ask it this way: Would you feel this way about this couple is they had different addresses?
Now, individually, Greg,
I don't dispute that, but the Bible does not prohibit anything outside of marriage except sex. Marriage is much more than the physical; but the physical is all that is prohibited. Again, think about what the Bible actually says. I understand that most of us (myself included) cannot imagine living in a house with a woman apart from sex. But it can be done. Again, I would ask, what does the Bible actually prohibit.
As to your bottomline, I cannot buy that at all. A grandparent can do a lot of things grandkids can't do. And I presume that you know your statement was not biblical.
Remember guys, my point is to get us back to what the Bible says. What is really wierd here about this, to me anyway, is that I am usually the one accuse of adding to Scripture when it comes to church membership and church involvement. I have been blasted for the view of the church that I take. Now you guys are telling me I need to raise it ... kind of humorous ... to me anyway ... -
Holding hands shows they are "more than friends"? That is just plain speculation and to insist they be married on this basis is crazy.
Shows of affection like holding hands, hugging etc, doesn't neccesarily mean that someone cares for another person on a "more than friendship basis".
Maybe it would be best to let these folks sing and stop over-analizing the situation. They've stated that they are not intimate, and you have no biblical support for condemning their sharing a home. -
Thirty years ago this kind of discussion would not have taken place. It was considered wrong in any circle I can think of. People were arrested for this type of behavior.
Sounds to me like yesterdays' taboo has become today's orthodoxy.
The Bible does not say that I cannot eat bacon but I will not when inviting a Jew to dine with me. "Freedom is not the right to do as please, but to please to do what is right."
Personally I could not marry them knowing that what they are asking is not above board. They are asking the pastor to be hush about marrying them. The right thing is never wrong. So why deviate from what is right. Our testimony is not a closet idea or philosophy but lived to be out before the world. We are not to be closet Christians. -
For the record, I am not arguing for the pastor to marry them in secret. I'm arguing that in their situation, they shouldn't be denied membership or service or singing in the chior based on the facts given in the OP.
-
-
That is horribly inconsistent. -
-
By the way, I talked to them and told them we as a church didn't feel right having them sing in the choir and living together. They still came Sunday morning and night and I pray they will do the right thing. The problem is we are a small church that was running about 10 when I was called to be the pastor last year, and they always let anybody help. They also have no guidelines for membership. You can just come forward and you are a member. We are now running about 50 so we need to pray and discuss coming up with some guidelines for people serving and joining the church.
This is my first pastorate, so I am learning everyday!! -
I honestly don't know if I would let them serve. I would certainly confront them about it and talk to them adn see what they had to say. But if we are going to talk about scriptural mandates, then they need to be scriptural. You can have non scriptural institutional standards for why a person cannot minister in teh church. That is fine ... just make sure you call them that.
Remember Scripture does not forbid "living together." It forbids immorality. -
What do you do with the becoming one part?
-
What do you mean "what do I do with it?" It doesn't have a lot to do with this situation so far as I can tell from what has been said. Here you have an older couple towards the twilight of their life finding companionship. Niether has a living spouse; they are not involved in sexual immorality. Based on what has said here, there is nothing biblical that they are violating ...
Becoming one is an important part of marriage. It does not apply to people who aren't married. -
Dear Brother Steveo,
I would first engage them in some pre-marital counseling.That is using scripture explain to them what marriage is as far as the church and God are concerned. It is unclear whether they are in love or not.It is unclear whether they are just trying to keep up appearances.I know it sounds strange to counsel a senior couple in this manner, however many couples are never properly counseled before marriage.
This could solve your problem if this cuople finds they are friends who are room mates and not in love.Biblical love has a much higher standard than our modern society has for marriage.
So I guess what I'm saying is first find out what thier real relationship is.Help them to find out what thier real relationship is. Then help them to do the right thing according to Biblical standards. Pray with them before and after counseling asking God to reveal His Truth in love and understanding.This kind of approach may help them to put everything in a proper spirtual context.After this is done you will know what to do. -
As far as getting to the scripture goes, you never did comment on the passages I submitted (Proverbs 31, Ephesians 5) that describe the way a marriage relationship should work. It is built on mutual love, care and submission to one another. To express the desire to be married "in God's eyes" should also be enough of a clue that even their consciences are telling them that this is more than a shared house arrangement. -
My focus has been on the point of biblical teaching about what is going on. There have been many statements made, none of which have been backed up by Scripture. Again, I have to ask, what exactly is this couple doing that is sinful?
We can say it isn't the best; it isn't good; it doesn't set a good example; etc. But to say it is sin, we need some statement from God. People can have close relationships without being married. They cross the line when it enters immorality. -
Pastor Larry,
What I'm trying to say about Gen 2:24 is who is it that should become one? I agree if they are just friends this wouldn't apply but if they are a couple(more than friends), shouldn't they get married?
If they hold hands and kiss, it is more than freinds.
Page 2 of 3