So being saved means getting to help with the sin problem? Thats a novel interpretation.
Saved in childbearing... from what?
Discussion in 'Baptist Theology & Bible Study' started by James_Newman, Aug 23, 2007.
Page 2 of 5
-
-
TCGreek said:1. You have made your point. Forgiving me for not taken into account the incorrect nature of "Let him or her know that they must return the books they borrowed."
2. Maybe I was wrong for using this faulty example. At any rate, the verdict is still out on this structure.Click to expand...
http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003485.html
So I will concede that this verse is certainly a strange one to decipher. -
I'd like to focus on the 'saved' part. I'll have to wait till tomorrow afternoon, though as I'm leaving for the day. Goodnight brothers.
-
I gotta question!!!!
does the word 'saved' in this passage have to mean or refer to the salvation of a woman's soul? -
Where does the Bible say that women can't teach?
I have pastored for many years and have yet to find a church that does not use women to teach women's classes and children's classes.Click to expand... -
menageriekeeper said:I gotta question!!!!
does the word 'saved' in this passage have to mean or refer to the salvation of a woman's soul?Click to expand... -
So being saved means getting to help with the sin problem? Thats a novel interpretation.Click to expand...
Study the passage rather than just spout off. Some interpretive keys are whether the salvation is spiritual or physical, what does the childbearing refer to (physical childbirth, general childbirth, the Messiah, etc.). One must answer all these questions before you can talk about novel interpretations.
Here's my view: Women were attempting to have spiritual influence over men through teaching and having authority in the church and in spiritual matters. Paul is teaching that that is not their salvation; their salvation (meaning something like their spiritual ministry or working out their own salvation) is through their ministry in the home.
Pick it apart if you wish, but at least deal with what I said. -
1 Timothy 2:14-15 And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression.
15 Notwithstanding she shall be saved in childbearing, if they continue in faith and charity and holiness with sobriety.
Genesis 3:16 Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee.
Paul is referring back to the curse that was put on Adam and Eve back in the Garden of Eden. Adam was not deceived. Eve was. Genesis 3:16 gives the consequence of Eve's sin--God would greatly multiply her sorrow and her conception; in sorrow she would bring forth children. Later Jesus mentioned how a woman brought forth a child in travail (or pain).
The "saved" is physical. Though the curse is in place, that the woman would give birth in sorrow; in pain, she would not die. She would be saved giving birth.
1 Timothy 2:15 and she shall be saved through the child-bearing, if they remain in faith, and love, and sanctification, with sobriety.
The pronoun is plural referring to the entire female gender--all women.
As elsewhere it is a passage that refers to the duties of a woman in the home. -
Pastor Larry said:It would help if you would read the context rather than make smart aleck remarks. I think when I said to look at the context that should have been the key to you to look at the context. If you have pastored for many years, then you know exactly what I was saying and it seems disingenuous to pretend otherwise.Click to expand...
You made a statement, of which I have read again, and I still would like to know the answer. -
DHK said:The "saved" is physical. Though the curse is in place, that the woman would give birth in sorrow; in pain, she would not die. She would be saved giving birth.
1 Timothy 2:15 and she shall be saved through the child-bearing, if they remain in faith, and love, and sanctification, with sobriety.
The pronoun is plural referring to the entire female gender--all women.
As elsewhere it is a passage that refers to the duties of a woman in the home.Click to expand... -
Accountable said:If, If, If,........... So what about the ones who do not remain in faith, and love, and sanctification, with sobriety?Click to expand...
If a woman lives a "loose life," drinks, and is immoral, she will do great harm not only to her unborn child but also to herself. And in Paul's day they didn't have the medical facilities that we do. The mortality rate was high for both children and mothers in that day. Even in third world countires today children that are born to Godly families have a better chance of survival, as do their mothers. -
Accountable said:I guess I'm just dumb. Where is the smart aleck remarks?
You made a statement, of which I have read again, and I still would like to know the answer.Click to expand... -
DHK said:It is a general guideline for righteous living. Think about it. What happens when one doesn't live "with sobriety" (soundness of mind).
If a woman lives a "loose life," drinks, and is immoral, she will do great harm not only to her unborn child but also to herself. And in Paul's day they didn't have the medical facilities that we do. The mortality rate was high for both children and mothers in that day. Even in third world countires today children that are born to Godly families have a better chance of survival, as do their mothers.Click to expand...
I did not know about the 3rd world statistics. Where can I find this? I have a file where I keep some statistics. -
DHK said:It is a general guideline for righteous living.Click to expand...
Exodus 20:12
"Honor your father and your mother, so that you may live long in the land the LORD your God is giving you.
Except that the emphasis was on duty to a parent rather than duty to a child.
I don't think this would mean that nobody ever died young that honored their parents, or that there were never any old geezers around that hadn't treated their parents honorably. But, as a general rule if you respect your folks you are more likely to hang around for awhile. -
lbaker said:Sort of the same general idea as:
Exodus 20:12
"Honor your father and your mother, so that you may live long in the land the LORD your God is giving you.
Except that the emphasis was on duty to a parent rather than duty to a child.
I don't think this would mean that nobody ever died young that honored their parents, or that there were never any old geezers around that hadn't treated their parents honorably. But, as a general rule if you respect your folks you are more likely to hang around for awhile.Click to expand... -
DHK said:Yes, that is a very good example of what I am trying to say.Click to expand...
-
Accountable said:Still looking for reply on the IF of faith, love, and sanctification.Click to expand...
If there is faith, love and holiness (sanctification) in the family, there is a much greater chance of both child and mother to be saved in child birth. -
DHK said:As Ibaker pointed out, it is a general rule to follow.
If there is faith, love and holiness (sanctification) in the family, there is a much greater chance of both child and mother to be saved in child birth.Click to expand...
Do we change the Bible, or do we change our thoughts? -
Accountable said:The Bible doesn't say she has a much greater chance to be saved, it says she shall be saved.
Do we change the Bible, or do we change our thoughts?Click to expand...
Page 2 of 5