Welcome to Baptist Board, a friendly forum to discuss the Baptist Faith in a friendly surrounding.
Your voice is missing! You will need to register to get access to all the features that our community has to offer.
We hope to see you as a part of our community soon and God Bless!
Of course, you'd be using the melodies of an agnostic mixing with hymn lyrics!!! A sign of the apocalypse!!gekko said:now - play that song on guitar to the tune of "crash" by dave matthews band - along with piano and violin accompany-ment - and you've got yourself a beautiful song.![]()
No point at all...just an attempt at humor. Of course notes don't have religion.gekko said:lol - your point?
music notes cannot be defined as agnostic or otherwise... it cannot be defined as secular or christian...
... sign of the apocalypse... lol
Music is NOT neutral.Linda said "Why desecrate the "blood of Jesus" with the world's music?"
again... as noted earlier - music has no religion. it is neither secular nor christian. it is simply neutral and can be used for both...
First of all, you need to read the biography of the hymn writer-- then you need to listen to the "original" tune of the hymn--the message of that hymn matches the music. Do some reading about hymns and hymn writers. Statements such as "how bout if that tune was made up by and old secular musician and was never thought of for that hymn" are simply childish nonsense which comes from one who has absolutely NO clue about how these old hymns of the faith were written. I will pray that the Lord will enlighten you!the original tune to "nothing but the blood of Jesus"... how bout if that tune was made up by and old secular musician and was never thought of for that hymn - and then we used it for that hymn?
you are too held up by the musical notes rather then the lyrics themselves.
but you will never understand that. and so i pray for you.
Plants are NOT people and plants do not have souls. The Bible DOES mention that we are NOT to be conformed to this world (and that includes worldly music)-Rom.12:1-2.its not the syncopated rythm that wilted the plants... its keeping them from the sunlight.
why does the bible not mention worldly music among the various lists of sins? hmm?
Secular rock music with Godly lyrics is NOT an encouragement in faith towards the God of Israel! If the music does not match the message, it is simply just another secular rock song with a "little" gospel topping (like chocolate syrup).gekko said:SFIC said "rock will add ambience to all the things above, you are correct. but you forgot to mention one other thing that it adds. it adds distance between man and God."
... does it now. i agree secular rock does. but Godly lyrics to a package of rock style music does not add distance - it is encouragement in faith towards the God of Israel.
this i know from experience.
---
gekko--your analogy (if you want to call it an analogy) doesn't make a lick of sense to me--never has and probably never will. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that bad apples will not become good apples if they are in the same barrel. Why do doctors quarantine people with contagious diseases? Arsenic that is put into a bowl of soup, does not become soup--the soup becomes poisonous. I could go on, but I am praying that you get the picture here.gekko said:Linda said "Putting Godly lyrics to worldly music does not make worldly music Godly. Does one bad apple in a barrel of good apples make the bad apple good?"
no no no... you did not read my analogy correctly.
let me say it here again:
if i coin a musical tune. (which sounds like "smells like teen spirit") - but let me say here that there is no such song as "smells like teen spirit" - never was - isn't and is not ever. (remember this is figurative) the tune we have today of "smells like teen spirit" - imagine that i had coined that tune some 3 years back - and put Godly lyrics to it. would it be a secular song - or a Godly song?
taking into consideration that there is no such band as nirvana - nor is there a song titled "smells like teen spirit" - but rather i have coined the tune as we know it today - 3 years back - and put Godly lyrics to it... would it be secular or Godly?
do you even understand my analogy?
If music is neutral, why do people want to dance to certain types of music? What about taking the music out of movies--if it's neutral, then it won't add anything to the movie, would it? Why are certain types of music played in shopping malls? If music is neutral, why do they only use Rock and Roll music to sell cars and commercials on TV--why not use gospel music or a children's song??? Obviously, certain types of music appeal to certain types of people--and it is blatantly obvious that Rock music appeals to you---otherwise you would not be talking about it so much. Are you trying to convince yourself that music is neutral--because you sure aren't convincing me.
He made it a hypothetical situation in that case, but some songs were adapted from secular tumes. You can even see this credited in the hymnals.First of all, you need to read the biography of the hymn writer-- then you need to listen to the "original" tune of the hymn--the message of that hymn matches the music. Do some reading about hymns and hymn writers. Statements such as "how bout if that tune was made up by and old secular musician and was never thought of for that hymn" are simply childish nonsense which comes from one who has absolutely NO clue about how these old hymns of the faith were written. I will pray that the Lord will enlighten you!
But since your side can find absolutely no scripture to prove that rock as a style is necessarily of the world, and traditional is not, many had resorted to citing science studies about rock wilting plants to prove it is "universally bad". Yet, other factors were often omitted, making those citations very unreliable. That's what he was addressing.Plants are NOT people and plants do not have souls. The Bible DOES mention that we are NOT to be conformed to this world (and that includes worldly music)-Rom.12:1-2.
Still, no one has ever shown that the old style used for hymns is not the same thing. There are plenty of old style songs that sound just like the hymns, (national anthems, etc) and your side says "oh well, that was from when society was more Christian", but that is debatable, and no matter how much you may think that, it was still "the world", and it is only your by association today that this sound is specifically "Christian".Just because you add Godly lyrics to secular music, DOES NOT MAKE IT GODLY--IT STILL REMAINS SECULAR MUSIC WITH GODLY LYRICS! What you are talking about is simply "sugar-coating" secular rock music with Godly lyrics. Coat a lemon with sugar--has the lemon changed? NO--there is still a lemon under all the sugar! When you add Godly lyrics to secular rock music, you compromise the gospel message. Jesus Christ does not rock--HE IS THE ROCK--HE IS GOD AND HE IS MY SAVIOR!